Domestic violence happened. Victims accused someone they know of physically assaulting them. The accuser later recants and tells a different story to the police or prosecutor. What happens if a domestic violence victim recants their statement?
Click here to watch the video on What Happens if a Domestic Violence Recants Their Statement – Michigan Law
Perhaps the victim didn’t retract. They failed to appear. The victim isn’t taking part in judicial activities. They simply turned docile. This can work in the offender’s favor. Most of the time, the court will grant the offender’s motion to have the case dismissed.
From the viewpoint of a witness who is making accusations, it will be different. You allegedly admit to making a fake report or lying while under oath. For filing a fraudulent police report, you will face legal action. You’ll face legal action for lying. Your actions could put you in legal trouble. You fail to appear. The outcome will be the same whether you take part or not. The case will be thrown out. Or, the prosecution will move forward regardless.
Domestic violence occurs between people who know each other. They are members of the same household. They are dating partners or other close relationships. This is the main distinction between domestic violence and other types of assault. domestic violence survivors dislike seeing someone so close to them punished. Prosecuting these crimes may be a very difficult task. Survivors might stop helping the police and prosecutors. They change their stories about the attacks.
What does recanting your statement mean? Why would victims recant their statements?
Domestic abuse survivors’ reports to the police will be used as evidence in the prosecution. It is the basis for criminal charges against the attacker. Recanting occurs when the survivor alters their account or retracts their entire claim. This can happen before, during, or after the trial. Recanting usually happens sooner to get the charges against the abuser dropped.
The majority of domestic abuse allegations in Michigan start with a call for help. The following occurs leading to criminal charges:
[ 1 ] The accused victim reports possible domestic violence. The report can also come from nearby witnesses, a bystander, or another party. The report describes some form of domestic abuse.
[ 2 ] When the police arrive, they will interview the claimed victim. The victim can be someone’s spouse, girlfriend, boyfriend, brother, parent, or another individual.
[ 3 ] The alleged offender will be taken into custody. This happens if there is good evidence to believe domestic violence has occurred,
[ 4 ] Police take pictures of the wounds and gather more proof.
[ 5 ] The prosecution will use the written statements from the victims to support its case.
There isn’t one common factor that causes survivors to retract their claims. The survivor’s relationship with the abuser frequently plays a significant role. It’s the anxiety of further violence if the attacker is exonerated. Or, when the accusations are withdrawn. This fear can be brought on by concern over how the assailant might resurface after serving time in jail. Local law enforcement may lack the resources. Logistical resources to ensure survivors are protected against perpetrators after they are released. This fear can be particularly severe.
Survivors often retract their statements out of guilt. The victimization of their attacker by the criminal justice system triggers this guilt. Researchers observed patterns in the interactions between abusers and victims of domestic violence. The assailants minimize the issue. They make an appeal for sympathy. Finally, they demand the victim recant.
Survivors can succumb to external pressure to recant. Their attacker plays a big role in their lives or in the life of someone close to them. A violent spouse is providing financial support for that person’s children. The victim doesn’t want to take the chance of making their violent spouse go to jail. The breadwinner abuser can no longer support the family while in prison. These recanting survivors may view enduring the abuse as less detrimental. Better than the alternative of being homeless or otherwise abandoned.
What is the impact of recanting on the domestic violence case?
A case is not withdrawn just because a victim no longer takes part in the case. It’s not like a civil case between two parties. A prosecutor’s or district attorney’s office handles criminal issues like domestic abuse. The victim can retract their testimonies. The prosecution can still pursue the case.
Many prosecutors are aware the victim would eventually change their story. The reliability of the trial will depend on the strength of the other available evidence. Recanting victims are very typical occurrences in domestic violence cases.
The prosecution can prove their case against the defendant with enough supporting evidence. Evidence or indicators of the crime include:
[ a ] Police reports
[ b ] Photos of injuries or property damage
[ c ] Recordings of any kind, including 911 calls
[ d ] Threats or statements published on social media
[ e ] Medical or health records
[ f ] Eyewitness testimony
The prosecution can move on even without the cooperation of the recanting survivor. There will be enough independent evidence. Authorities expect victims of domestic violence will retract their allegations. Prosecutors may even use tactics more common in homicide trials. They proceed to believe there won’t be a survivor to testify.
In many situations of domestic violence, the victim’s testimony is key. The victim’s statements link everything together. When the police arrive, the victim can choose to make their statement there. They can proceed to the police station. Defendants and victims can reconcile after an incident. It’s possible that there was a miscommunication. It caused the altercation, and things got out of hand.
Domestic violence survivors can always alter their accounts. Prosecutors cannot always move forward with the case. Often the perpetrator is never brought to justice. This leaves the victim vulnerable to more domestic abuse.
The victims recanting can work in favor of the abuser or defendant if the evidence is not convincing and overwhelming. Keep in mind a few important facts if you’re the defendant in one of these situations.
[ a ] The charge won’t be dismissed if the victim retracts their testimony. Not even if the victim declines to appear in court. The prosecution can have a harder time establishing its case. The prosecution can still do so without the victim. Once a case is filed, it can only be dropped by the prosecutor or the court.
[ b ] The terms of an order of protection are enforced even if the victim retracts their statement. Until the court lifts the order, you shouldn’t communicate with the victim.
It’s critical to comprehend the details of your case. You’ve been accused of domestic abuse. Develop a defense plan that addresses the pertinent issues. Talk to your attorney about the details of this defense.
What is the impact of recanting on the victim?
The victim and defendant in a domestic quarrel can reconcile in some cases. The victim may call the police or the prosecutor’s office after the reported incident. The victim will try to retract their complaint or have the charges dropped. The majority of prosecutors will nonetheless continue with the case.
Victims can testify in court to alter their accounts. The prosecution can refute the victim’s testimony. Argue that she is distorting the truth to “rescue” the offender from conviction. The victim’s initial statement can be sustained as true by judges and juries. It was made in a frenzied state. The victim’s statement is trustworthy. There was no time for fabrication.
Victims can be charged with perjury. They can be held accountable for making a false police complaint. They can be charged with interfering with the legal process. They can be cited with contempt of court or other penalties if they ignore a subpoena. Talk to your attorney first before considering recanting your statement if youre the victim. Your life and safety are at stake in this case.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel today for more advice on Family Law!
Goldman & Associates Law Firm is here to with information about Child Custody and Divorce in the State of Michigan.